Is Your University’s Student Health Plan Worth the Cost? Or Should You Waive It?

Student Health Insurance

The Mandatory Fee You Might Be Able to Avoid

When I started grad school, I was automatically billed almost $3,000 for the university’s student health insurance plan (SHIP). I almost just paid it. But then I looked closer. Because I was still under 26, I was eligible to stay on my parents’ high-quality PPO plan. I had to fill out an online “waiver” form, providing proof of my existing coverage. Once the university verified my insurance met their requirements, they removed the charge from my tuition bill. It was a 15-minute task that saved me thousands of dollars.

Is Your University’s Student Health Plan Worth the Cost? Or Should You Waive It?

A Cost-Benefit Analysis for Your College Years

Most universities automatically enroll you in their Student Health Insurance Plan (SHIP) and charge the premium to your tuition bill. Before you pay, do a comparison. If you are under 26, you can likely stay on your parents’ plan. Compare the monthly cost, the deductible, and the provider network of the SHIP to your parents’ plan. For my friend whose parents had a high-deductible plan, the university’s low-deductible SHIP was actually a better and cheaper option. For me, staying on my parents’ plan was the smarter move. You have to do the math.

How I Saved $2,000 By Waiving My College’s Health Plan

The Simple Form That Kept Money in My Pocket

My college charged a mandatory $2,000 annual fee for their student health plan. But they offered a waiver if you could prove you had other “comparable” coverage. I was still on my dad’s excellent PPO plan from his job. I went to my college’s health services website, filled out the online waiver form, and entered my insurance information from my dad’s plan. A few weeks later, I saw a $2,000 credit on my student account. It’s a crucial step every student should take before paying their tuition bill.

Understanding Student Health Insurance Coverage: On-Campus vs. Off-Campus Care

The Two Tiers of Your University Plan

A student health plan typically works in two tiers. For basic needs—a cold, a minor injury, a prescription refill—you are encouraged to use the on-campus Student Health Center, often for a very low co-pay. For more serious issues or to see a specialist, the plan has a network of off-campus doctors and hospitals in the local area. It’s important to understand this structure. Using the on-campus center is convenient and cheap for minor things, but you need to know which local hospitals and specialists are in-network for more serious medical needs.

Can You Stay on Your Parents’ Health Insurance Until 26? Usually Yes (And It Might Be Better)

The ACA Provision That’s Perfect for Students

Thanks to the Affordable Care Act, you can remain on your parents’ health insurance plan until you turn 26, regardless of whether you are a student, are financially independent, or are married. For most college students, this is the best and most cost-effective option. Employer-sponsored plans, especially from large companies, often have better networks and lower out-of-pocket costs than a university’s student health plan. Before you accept the SHIP, always check to see if staying on your parents’ plan is a possibility.

Comparing Your Parents’ Plan vs. the Student Health Insurance Plan (SHIP)

A Head-to-Head Matchup

When deciding whether to waive the SHIP, create a simple comparison chart. For each plan (your parents’ vs. the SHIP), list the monthly premium, the annual deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum, and, most importantly, the provider network in your college town. My parents’ plan had a higher deductible, but it also had a broad national PPO network that included all the local hospitals. The SHIP had a lower deductible but a very narrow HMO network. For me, the better network access of my parents’ plan made it the clear winner.

Does Student Health Insurance Cover Mental Health Counseling?

An Increasingly Important and Utilized Benefit

Yes, most modern, ACA-compliant student health insurance plans are required to cover mental health services as an essential health benefit. This is a crucial feature for college students. Your plan will likely provide a certain number of free counseling sessions at the on-campus counseling center. For more intensive therapy or to see an off-campus psychiatrist, you would be subject to the plan’s regular co-pays and deductibles. Given the high stress of college life, understanding and utilizing your plan’s mental health benefits is incredibly important.

What Happens to Student Health Insurance During Summer Break or If You Study Abroad?

Check Your Coverage Before You Travel

This is a critical detail to verify. Most student health plans provide year-round coverage, so you are still covered during summer break, even if you are back in your hometown. However, the network of doctors might be limited to your college town. For study abroad, the rules vary. My SHIP had a partnership that provided excellent international travel health insurance. My friend’s plan did not, and she had to purchase a separate travel medical policy for her semester in Spain. Always check the policy’s rules for out-of-area and international coverage.

Filing Claims with Student Health Insurance: The Process

Let the Provider’s Office Do the Work

Filing a claim with a student health plan is usually simple. If you use the on-campus health center, there are typically no claims to file; it’s all handled internally. If you go to an in-network, off-campus doctor, their office will handle the claims process for you. You will just provide your insurance ID card, and they will bill the insurance company directly. You will then receive a bill for your portion of the cost (your co-pay or deductible). It’s designed to be a low-hassle process for busy students.

Meeting Waiver Requirements: Proving You Have Comparable Coverage

You Need to Show Proof of a “Real” Plan

To waive your university’s SHIP, you can’t just say you have other insurance. You have to prove it. The university will have a list of minimum requirements that your other plan must meet. This typically includes being an ACA-compliant plan, having a provider network that is accessible in the area of the university, and having a reasonable deductible. You will need to provide the name of your insurance carrier, your policy number, and your group number on the waiver form. They will then verify this information.

International Students: Navigating US Health Insurance Requirements

A Mandatory and Often Confusing Requirement

For international students studying in the U.S., health insurance is not optional; it is a mandatory requirement for maintaining your student visa status. Most universities will require you to enroll in their student health insurance plan. The U.S. healthcare system is incredibly complex and expensive, and the university wants to ensure you are protected. While the cost may seem high, going without coverage is not an option. It is a necessary expense to protect you from the astronomical cost of American healthcare.

Using the On-Campus Student Health Center vs. Off-Campus Providers

Your First Stop for Most Medical Needs

The on-campus student health center is the hub of most university health plans. It’s the best place to go for common illnesses, minor injuries, vaccinations, and basic prescriptions. The services are often provided at a very low or zero co-pay. The doctors and nurses at the health center can handle about 80% of a student’s medical needs. If you need to see a specialist or require more advanced care, they will then provide you with a referral to an in-network, off-campus provider. Always start at the health center.

Prescription Drug Coverage Under Student Health Plans

Understanding Your Formulary and Tiers

Student health plans have a prescription drug benefit, but it’s important to understand how it works. The plan will have a “formulary,” which is a list of covered drugs, organized into tiers. Tier 1 is generic drugs, with the lowest co-pay. Tier 2 is preferred brand-name drugs, with a higher co-pay. And Tier 3 is non-preferred brand-name drugs, with the highest co-pay. Before enrolling, you should check the plan’s formulary to make sure any ongoing medications you take are covered at a reasonable cost.

Does Student Health Insurance Cover Pre-Existing Conditions? Usually Yes (If ACA Compliant)

The Protection of the Affordable Care Act

If your university’s student health insurance plan is ACA-compliant (and most are), then it is required by law to cover pre-existing conditions. It cannot deny you coverage or charge you more because you have a condition like asthma, diabetes, or Crohn’s disease. This is a critical protection that ensures all students have access to the care they need, regardless of their health history. It’s one of the most important features to confirm about any student health plan.

The Cost of Student Health Insurance: Factoring It Into College Expenses

A Significant, and Often Overlooked, Line Item

When families are budgeting for college, they focus on tuition, room, and board. They often overlook the cost of health insurance. A student health insurance plan can cost anywhere from $2,000 to $4,000 per academic year. This is a significant expense that needs to be factored into your overall cost of attendance. If you are planning to waive the SHIP and stay on a parent’s plan, be sure to account for any extra premium your parent might have to pay to keep you on their plan.

What Happens After Graduation? Losing Student Health Coverage (Qualifying Event)

Your Next Step in the Insurance Journey

Graduation is a major life event, and it also means you will be losing your student health insurance coverage. The good news is that this loss of coverage is a “Qualifying Life Event.” This grants you a 60-day Special Enrollment Period to get new coverage. You can either enroll in your new employer’s health plan, purchase a plan on the ACA marketplace (where you may get a subsidy), or, if you are still under 26, you can be added to your parents’ health plan.

Dental and Vision Options Alongside Student Health Insurance

Usually Separate, Optional Plans

Your main student health insurance plan does not typically include routine dental or vision coverage. However, most universities will offer separate, optional dental and vision insurance plans that you can enroll in for an additional premium. These plans are often very affordable and can provide great value if you wear glasses or contacts or know you will need dental work. During your enrollment period, you should evaluate these voluntary plans to see if they make sense for your specific needs.

My Advice: Carefully Evaluate the Student Health Plan Before Enrolling or Waiving

Don’t Default to a Decision

My best advice for any college student is to be proactive about your health insurance. Don’t just automatically pay the SHIP premium on your tuition bill, and don’t just automatically waive it. Take 30 minutes to do a side-by-side comparison. Look at the premiums, the deductibles, the out-of-pocket maximums, and most importantly, the provider networks of the student plan versus your parents’ plan. Making an informed decision based on your specific health needs and location can save you thousands of dollars and a lot of headaches.

Understanding Deductibles and Copays on Student Plans

Your Share of the Costs

Like any health plan, a SHIP will require you to pay a share of your medical costs. The deductible is the amount you have to pay out-of-pocket before the insurance starts paying its share. A co-pay is a fixed fee you pay for a specific service, like a $25 co-pay for a specialist visit. And co-insurance is a percentage of the bill you pay after you’ve met your deductible. Understanding these terms is key to predicting what your actual out-of-pocket costs will be when you need to use your insurance.

Does Student Health Insurance Travel With You? (Network Limitations)

It Depends on the Network Type

Whether your student health plan provides good coverage when you travel depends on its network. If it’s an HMO with a local network, you will likely only have coverage for emergency care when you are outside of your college town. If it’s a PPO with a broad, national network, you will be able to find in-network doctors and hospitals all across the country. This is a crucial feature to check if you plan to travel frequently or if your permanent home is in a different state than your university.

Student Health Insurance: Ensuring Access to Care While You Study

The Bottom Line: Protection for Your Health and Finances

College is a time of immense growth and opportunity. The last thing you want is for a medical issue to derail your studies or your finances. A student health insurance plan, whether it’s the university’s plan or a parent’s plan, is a non-negotiable part of being a student. It ensures that you have access to the medical care you need, when you need it, without the risk of incurring a massive, unmanageable medical bill. It’s a safety net that allows you to focus on what matters most: your education.

Scroll to Top